Wednesday, August 17, 2005

Banks and Credit Derivatives

Minton, Stulz, and Williamson have an important look at banks' usage of credit derivatives. The short version? Very few banks are using them! In 2003, only about 6% of banks with over $1B in assets report using this form of derivatives. Consistent with what we have seen on other derviatve usage, these banks tend to be much larger than average. Best guess as for the low usage? Transaction costs driven by moral hazard and adverse selection costs.

Slightly longer version of the paper

Minton, Stulz, and Williamson begin by documenting that the credit derivative market (measured by notional principle) has grown in recent years. Regulators (and even Alan Greenspan himself) have claimed that this reduces the risks that banks face. The paper investigates banks' use of credit derivatives and find that as of 2003, few banks were using credit derivatives. Those banks that were using the derivatives tended to be larger and have a greater need for the risk reduction.

In the words of the paper's authors:

" buyers of protection have higher levels of risk than other banks: they have lower capital ratios, lower balances of liquid assets, a higher ratio of risk-based assets to total assets, and a higherfraction of non-performing assets than the non-users of credit derivatives."
Why the limited use? Transaction costs undoubtedly play a role. Like in other derivatives "know-how" can be expensive to obtain and this largely fixed cost may explain a portion of the limited use. However, the very nature of credit derivatives also makes them prone to moral hazard and adverse selection costs. (Tried another way, banks typcially know more about the borrowers (and are often in a better position to monitor), than do derivative market participants. This results in less liquidity (higher transaction costs) for the very loans that would make the most sense to hedge.)

Again in the authors' words:

"These adverse selection and moral hazard problems make the market for credit derivatives illiquid for singlename protection precisely for the credit risks that banks would often want to hedge with such protection. The positive coefficient estimates on C&I loan and foreign loan shares in a bank’s loan portfolio are consistent with the hypothesis that banks are more likely to hedge with credit derivatives if they havemore loans to credits for which the credit derivatives market is more liquid."

So what does this all mean? The conclusion hints that the benefits of credit derivatives may be overstated but apparently teh cost of hedging in papers is lower than in the credit derivative market as the paper ends covering both sides of the debate:

"To the extent that credit derivatives make it easier for banks to maximize their value with less capital, they do not increase the soundness of banks as much as their purchases of credit derivatives would imply. However, if credit derivatives enable banks to save capital, they ultimately reduce the cost of loans for bank customers and make banks morecompetitive with the capital markets for the provision of loans."

Not only are few banks using the derivatives to hedge, the exact loans that the banks would want to hedge are the most expensive to do. This really should not be surprising. What is more surprising is that these costs are so high as to prevent the use of the derivatives. Going forward in time, it will be interesting to see if this remains the case or if as the market develops, new ways evolve to lower the costs which would allow more effective hedging with credit derivatives. Stay Tuned.

Minton, Bernadette A, Rene Stulz, and Rohan Williamson. "How much do banks use credit derivatives to reduce risk?", Ohio State working paper,, accessed 8/17/05

4 comments: said...

Debt Management, Consolidation Loans & Elimination Programs

It's time to do something about your debt. Millions of Americans have a wallet full of credit cards--plus expensive personal loans, auto loans, second mortgages and more. you're tired of paying 10%, 15%, 19% and more on your credit cards, auto loans, personal loans and other types of credit, today is the day to wipe the slate clean and start over. A debt consolidation loan can lower your interest rate, combine all your accounts into just one convenient monthly payment and give you some extra breathing room in your budget. You'll save money now - and at tax time too (be sure to consult your tax advisor for details.)

With mortgage interest rates the lowest they've been in decades, now is the perfect time to refinance your home and pay off all those nagging bills. You can count on America's Lending Partners FREE service to help you lower your interest rate, pay off those nagging bills and cut your monthly payments by as much as $300, $450, even $500 or more.

Start your request at left. Then, we'll match your profile with our nationwide network of lenders. You'll get up to 4 great offers from some of the most prominent and respected refinance debt consolidation lenders in America...each presenting their absolute best loan offer to win your business

Do not wait any longer; now is the time to take charge of your debt situation. Feel free to brows our site for more information, or for a free, no obligation debt quote, fill out a quick response form on your left, or click here for a free debt quote.

If your in debt... you're not alone. Today, millions of Americans are having difficulty paying their debts. Most of those in financial distress are middle income families with jobs who want to pay off what they owe.

Now is the time to act! Doing nothing can lead to much larger problems.


Free Loan Request - Get Up To 4 Loan Offers!

**** You must own a home to qualify for this service. ****

geldlening said...

Hi Blogger! Ik ben op zoek naar een geldlening Zou Afab echt zo goed zijn als iedereen beweert? Of kan ik beter zoiets als Geldshop proberen?

Groetjes Albert

lening said...

Hi Blogger! Ik ben op zoek naar een lening Zou Afab echt zo goed zijn als iedereen beweert? Of kan ik beter zoiets als Geldshop proberen?

Groetjes Albert

Anonymous said...

Debt Consolidation Debt Consolidation Programs can help you reduce your interest burden by charging an interest rate lower than the rate on your existing loans. Debt consolidation loan can also allow you to make small monthly payments by extending the loan period