@JimMahar (Twitter feed)

    follow me on Twitter

    Search This Blog and things linked to from here

    Loading...

    Shared Items

    BonaResponds Slideshow

    Loading...

    I^3: Important, Interesting, and Informative

    I^3: The Best Articles from the past. GREAT for class.

    Top Finance Papers from SSRN

    Labels from past posts

    The SSRN Blog

    Larry Schrenk's FinanceBasics From Univ of Baltimore

    Latest Issue of The Journal of Finance

    The Aleph Blog

    Top25 from ScienceDriect in Econ/Finance

    WSJ Community - Group: Academic Finance

    RandomTopics2

    Monday, June 15, 2009

    MLB: Wins and Payroll, a fast fast fast midseason look

    Ok, so this is a really bad study (It took all of three minutes to do), but I found it interesting.

    Data was sketchy at best and definitley would not hold up even in class let alone a paper, but like I said it took three minutes.


    Y is number of wins right as of 1Am eastern today (June 15) (and yes I know some teams have played more games), X1 is payroll as reported by USA Today, X2 is number of players CURRENTLY on the disabled list.

    Wins= 26.85 + (4.75E-08)Payroll
    Payroll is significant at the 4% level (t=2.23)

    Which is expected, pay more for talent get more wins.

    What is interesting is to see how well this simple simple simple model predicts wins. (spreadsheet below). The best? The Red Sox. The Worst? The Nationals. The Mets? about 2 fewer ganes than would be expected (given they have one extra game to play than many teams AND won at least 8/9ths of the Friday game, I found this a good sign). LOL.

    Then using a very noisy variable for injuries (Hey I am a Met fan, I get to use injuries as an excuse):

    Y is number of wins right as of 1Am eastern today (June 15) (and yes I know some teams have played more games), X1 is payroll as reported by USA Today, X2 is number of players CURRENTLY on the disabled list.

    Wins= 29.93 + (4.11E-08)(Payroll) + (-0.51627)(number of players CURRENTLY on DL)

    t-stat for payroll 1.93, t stat for players on DL= -1.45

    So point estimates are in the expected direction but not significant using normal levels. Tjis might be because of the failure to differentiate injury severity (15 vs 60 day DL), importance of player (a mop up player has the same weight as a Jose Reyes or Carlos Delgado), or the total number of games lost (literally this is just the number of players reported by Yahoo that are CURRENTLY) on the DL.

    Team payroll Injuries wins expected wins based off of payroll Wins - expected wins
    Yankees 201449189 5 36 36.414706 -0.41471
    Mets 148373987 8 32 33.896147 -1.89615
    cubs 134809000 3 30 33.252453 -3.25245
    red sox 121745999 3 38 32.632579 5.367421
    tigers 115085145 3 34 32.316504 1.683496
    angels 113709000 3 32 32.251202 -0.2512
    phillies 113004046 3 36 32.21775 3.78225
    astros 102996414 4 29 31.742861 -2.74286
    mariers 98904166 6 30 31.548673 -1.54867
    braves 96726166 7 30 31.445322 -1.44532
    white sox 96068500 2 30 31.414114 -1.41411
    Giants 82616450 2 34 30.775778 3.224222
    indians 81579166 7 29 30.726556 -1.72656
    blue jays 80538300 5 34 30.677165 3.322835
    brewers 80182502 2 34 30.660281 3.339719
    cardianals 77605109 4 34 30.537977 3.462023
    rockies 75201000 4 31 30.423895 0.576105
    reds 73558500 3 31 30.345955 0.654045
    diamondbacks 73516666 6 27 30.343969 -3.34397
    royals 70519333 7 28 30.201738 -2.20174
    rangers 68178798 8 35 30.090673 4.909327
    orioles 67101666 4 27 30.039561 -3.03956
    twins 65299266 3 32 29.954032 2.045968
    rays 63313034 9 34 29.85978 4.14022
    As 62310000 7 27 29.812183 -2.81218
    nationals 60328000 7 16 29.718132 -13.7181
    pirates 48693000 5 30 29.166021 0.833979
    padres 43734200 7 28 28.930713 -0.93071
    marlins 36834000 5 32 28.60328 3.39672

    1 comments:

    John said...

    You should try to re-run it with the payroll of the players on the injured reserve (if the data is available). I would expect that a player with a higher salary who is on the injured list has a greater negative effect on the record than a no-name player.

    Welcome

    Academic Papers, notes, finance videos, links to classes, reading lists and more. Enjoy!
    Jim

    Have a suggested paper or article? Email me JimMahar at Yahoo.com


    BonaResponds Twitter Updates

    BonaSIMM

    The Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance and Financial Regulation

    Nudge blog

    Predictably Irrational

    Simoleon Sense

    The Psy-Fi Blog

    SBUSchoolofBusiness

    Knowledge@Wharton Interviews

    Bloomberg - All Podcasts

    The Curious Capitalist

    Marketplace

    The Wall Street Journal CEO Radio

    Wall Street Journal What's News

    FinanceClass

    Blog Archive

    Other Blogs of Interest

    FinanceProfessor.com Podcast

    WSJ Opinions